In the annals of Byzantine history, few religious movements sparked as much conflict and controversy as Paulicianism. Flourishing primarily between the 7th and 9th centuries in the eastern parts of the Byzantine Empire, particularly Anatolia and Armenia, the Paulicians were a Christian sect regarded as heretical by the mainstream Orthodox Church. Their dualistic theology and rejection of key ecclesiastical structures led to centuries of persecution, rebellion, and even military confrontation.
Origins and Early Leaders
The origins of Paulicianism are somewhat debated and obscured by hostile sources. The movement is traditionally traced back to Constantine-Silvanus, an Armenian living near Samosata in the mid-7th century. According to Byzantine accounts (often written by their opponents, like Patriarch Photius), Constantine received a copy of the New Testament, specifically the Gospels and the Epistles of Paul. Deeply influenced by these texts, he began preaching a return to what he saw as primitive Christianity, rejecting the accumulating traditions and hierarchy of the established church. He took the name Silvanus, after one of Paul’s companions, suggesting a desire to emulate the apostles.
The name “Paulician” itself likely derives from Paul – either the Apostle Paul, whose writings they particularly revered and sought to emulate, or possibly from an earlier leader or location.
After Constantine-Silvanus was executed by Byzantine authorities, the movement continued under a succession of leaders. One of the most significant was Sergius-Tychicus, who led the Paulicians for over 30 years in the late 8th and early 9th centuries. He organized the scattered communities, preached extensively, and further solidified their distinct beliefs.
Core Beliefs
The defining characteristic of Paulicianism was its form of dualism. Unlike the absolute dualism of Manichaeism (with two co-eternal, equally powerful principles of good and evil), Paulician dualism was often seen as a mitigated or ‘ditheist’ form. They believed in two gods:
A good, spiritual God who was the ruler of heaven and the spiritual realm, and the father of Jesus Christ.
An evil demiurge, the creator of the material world, the flesh, and the Old Testament law. This evil god was often identified with the God of the Old Testament.
This foundational dualism led to a radical rejection of many aspects of mainstream Christianity and the material world associated with the evil creator:
Rejection of the Old Testament: Seen as the work of the demiurge.
Rejection of Icons and Relics: Considered idolatrous material objects.
Rejection of Sacraments: They often rejected or reinterpreted baptism and the Eucharist, seeing them as material rituals without true spiritual efficacy. They may have practiced a form of spiritual baptism.
Rejection of the Church Hierarchy: They had no priests, bishops, or formal church buildings as understood by the Orthodox Church. Their leaders were charismatic teachers known as synecdemi (fellow travellers) or elect.
Rejection of the Cross as a Symbol: While venerating Christ, they saw the physical cross as a material object of suffering related to the evil world, not a suitable object of worship.
Christology: Their belief in Jesus Christ was central, but often interpreted through a dualistic lens. They tended towards adoptionism (Christ was a man adopted by God) or docetism (Christ’s body was not truly physical, but only seemed so), fitting their rejection of matter.
Instead of complex rituals and church structures, Paulicians emphasised personal faith, moral conduct, and the study of specific New Testament texts (primarily the Gospels and Paul’s Epistles). Their gatherings were simple, focussed on teaching and spiritual guidance.
Persecution and Rebellion
The Paulicians’ distinct beliefs and their formation into separate communities were seen as a direct threat to the religious and political unity of the Byzantine Empire, where Orthodoxy was the state religion. Consequently, they faced intermittent but often brutal persecution from the Byzantine authorities, starting as early as the late 7th century.
This persecution forced them to become mobile, sometimes seeking refuge in border regions or under Arab rule. It also hardened their resolve. By the 9th century, under pressure from intensifying campaigns (notably under Emperor Michael I and Empress Theodora, who reportedly massacred thousands), the Paulicians in some areas transformed from a primarily religious movement into a significant military and political force.
Under leaders like Karbeas and his successor Chrysocheir, based in strongholds like Tephrike (modern Divriği in Turkey), they formed alliances with the Arab emirates bordering Byzantium. They launched devastating raids deep into Byzantine territory, sacking cities and taking captives, turning the tables on their persecutors. This period of military resistance reached its peak in the mid-9th century but eventually waned after Byzantine counter-offensives, which led to the destruction of Tephrike in 878.
Relocation and Legacy
Following military defeats, many Paulicians were forcibly relocated by the Byzantines, notably to Thrace (the Balkan region including parts of modern Greece, Bulgaria, and Turkey). This strategic move aimed to break their power in Anatolia and use them as a military buffer or settlers in new areas.
However, this relocation had an unintended consequence: it brought Paulician ideas into contact with new populations, particularly in the Balkans. While the direct line of descent is debated by scholars, Paulicianism is widely considered a significant precursor and influencing factor for later dualist movements, most famously the Bogomils who emerged in Bulgaria in the 10th century. The Bogomils shared many theological similarities with the Paulicians, including dualism, rejection of church hierarchy and rituals, and criticism of the material world.
By the late Middle Ages, Paulician communities in the Balkans had largely disappeared, either assimilated into the local populations (Orthodox or later, under Ottoman rule, sometimes converting to Islam) or merging with other similar dissenting groups.
Paulicianism represented a persistent and resilient form of Christian dissent in the heartland of the Byzantine Empire. Driven by a dualistic worldview and a desire to return to a perceived simpler, more spiritual form of Christianity based on the New Testament, they challenged the established church and state for centuries. Their story is one of theological controversy, relentless persecution, military resistance, and survival, leaving a legacy that arguably contributed to the landscape of religious dissent and dualist thought in medieval Europe, particularly in the Balkans. Despite hostile historical sources, the Paulicians stand as a testament to the diverse and often tumultuous religious landscape of the Byzantine era.
Worldwide Temple of Aurora 