The Tug of War: Mother Nature vs. Free Will

In the intricate tapestry of human existence, there lies a fascinating interplay between biological instincts and the edifice of cultural mores and personal beliefs. This duality raises profound questions about just how much of our behaviour is dictated by nature—our evolutionary history and biological imperatives—versus how much is informed by nurture, societal expectations, and conscious choices.

The Allure of Evolution

Take, for instance, the evolution of physical traits that contribute to attraction. Women’s breasts, an intrinsic aspect of female physiology, have been posited to develop not just for infant nourishment but also as a signal of fertility and health. The silhouette of cleavage, which closely mimics the shape of the female posterior, has been theorised to play into the visual preferences of men, tapping into a primal instinct that favours reproductive viability. Yet, society imposes a Gospel of respect, cautioning men against objectification and encouraging a view of women beyond their physical forms. This societal narrative intersects with the biological drive, creating a tension where instincts may clamour for acknowledgment even as cultural norms advocate for restraint and awareness. Research has also shown that men are more likely to be attracted to women with a low waist-to-hip ratio, a trait that signals high fertility and reproductive potential. These instinctual preferences can lead men to prioritise physical attractiveness over other qualities, such as intelligence or kindness. It seems that whilst Mother Nature promotes the survival of the species, by encouraging sexual reproduction at a fundamental level, this factor may, or may not, always align with cultural beliefs held at certain times in human history.

The Role of Pheromones and Maternal Instinct

The biological workings of human attraction don’t stop at physical appearances. The world of pheromones—chemical signals that influence behaviour—opens a window into another fascinating aspect of our evolutionary design. Research indicates that women, particularly those exposed to the cries and scents of babies, are often compelled to nurture. These pheromonal cues trigger an instinctive yearning for motherhood, spurring a collective empathy among women. At a biological level, this shared desire strengthens social bonds that benefit communal child-rearing, yet contemporary cultural contexts sometimes urge women to postpone motherhood or pursue personal ambitions. Here again, nature’s instincts wrestle with modern life choices. Once again, nature promotes the survival of the species, by encouraging women to become pregnant, under the influence of pheromones.

Sexual Dynamics and Hormonal Influence

Women’s sexual behaviour further exemplifies this interplay. Scientific research reveals that hormonal fluctuations throughout the menstrual cycle significantly influence sexual motivation and partner selection. For instance, studies have demonstrated that women may exhibit increased attraction to potential mates during the fertile phase of their cycles, suggesting that biology plays a critical role in shaping sexual dynamics. However, social narratives often endorse monogamy and fidelity, complicating the biological urge with moral considerations and expectations. The result is a friction where human instincts are at odds with the commitment often deemed necessary in contemporary relationships. Once again, we encounter another example of the subtle ever-present influence of Mother Nature.

Instinctual Responses: Fight, Flight, or Freeze

When we consider the more primal instincts, the “fight, flight, or freeze” response highlights another arena in which Mother Nature exerts her influence. In stressful or threatening situations, these instinctive actions serve as a survival mechanism designed to keep individuals safe and viable. Yet, societal frameworks often place constraints on how we react. In many cultures, the expectation may be to confront fears head-on—no matter the instinct prompting retreat. This presents a challenge: when the innate response diverges from cultural expectations, individuals may experience internal conflict, questioning whether to adhere to their instincts or societal norms.

The Balance Between Nature and Nurture

Ultimately, examining the interplay between these instinctual behaviours and cultural norms reveals the complexity of human nature. As human beings, we are products of both our biological inheritance and the social constructs that shape our lives. The evolutionary impulses that urge us toward attraction, reproduction, and survival are countered by cultural mores that encourage particular behaviours and egalitarian principles. This dissonance highlights the broader challenge of harmonising our evolutionary inclinations with culturally constructed norms. The result can be anything from puzzlement to guilt as individuals struggle to reconcile their instinctual responses with the values instilled by their environments.

Recognising this tension invites a greater understanding of ourselves and how we navigate the world around us. It highlights the need for compassion—for both ourselves and others—as we strive for a balance between our instinctive drives and the ethical frameworks we cultivate. This ongoing struggle between what instinct urges and what society dictates remains a central facet of the human experience, a testament to the intricate dancing of Mother Nature and free will within us all.

Recommended reading: (1) Brain Sex, by Anne Moir and David Jessel, (2) The Female Brain, by Dr Louann Brizendine (3) The Mail Brain, by Dr Louann Brizendine, (4) Mapping The Mind, by Rita Carter.

Kerin Webb has a deep commitment to personal and spiritual development. Here he shares his insights at the Worldwide Temple of Aurora.