On solemn occasions, from the grandeur of Easter services in Moscow cathedrals to Victory Day parades and political inaugurations, a recurring image captures global attention: Vladimir Putin, the President of Russia, flanked or accompanied by senior figures of the Russian Orthodox Church. These appearances are carefully curated, steeped in symbolism, and intended to project an image of national unity, historical continuity, and spiritual legitimacy. Yet, for many observers both inside and outside Russia, these very images highlight a profound and troubling hypocrisy.
The core of this perceived hypocrisy lies in the fundamental disconnect between the core tenets espoused by Christianity – peace, compassion, truth, justice, care for the poor and vulnerable, condemning violence and deceit – and the actions and policies enacted by the state under President Putin, particularly his prosecution of the war in Ukraine, widely condemned for its brutality, civilian casualties, and alleged war crimes.
Religious leaders, especially priests and bishops, are traditionally seen as moral shepherds, guiding their flock according to divine principles. Their presence alongside a political leader inherently suggests an endorsement or, at the very least, a tolerance of that leader and their actions. When these actions include initiating a devastating war, causing immense suffering, and relying heavily on propaganda and alleged falsehoods, the juxtaposition with figures representing a faith centred on love and truth becomes starkly contradictory.
Critics argue that the Russian Orthodox Church, under the leadership of Patriarch Kirill, has become deeply entwined with the Russian state, essentially acting as a spiritual arm of the Kremlin. This relationship is not entirely new; the Church has historically navigated complex relations with state power in Russia. However, under Putin, this alliance has solidified, with the Church actively promoting a nationalist ideology that often blends religious fervour with loyalty to the state and its foreign policy objectives.
Senior clergy, including Patriarch Kirill himself, have not only appeared with Putin but have also offered theological justifications for the war in Ukraine, framing it in spiritual terms as a defence against Western decadence and liberalism. This rhetoric directly contradicts the universal call for peace and reconciliation found in Christian scripture and tradition. Their silent presence or overt blessings during ceremonies tied to state power, particularly military power, lends a veneer of divine approval to actions that many Christians worldwide find abhorrent.
This creates a moral dilemma for both the clergy and the faithful. For the priests appearing with Putin, their presence can be interpreted as prioritising institutional power and political alignment over universal ethical principles. For the faithful, it presents a dissonance between the Gospel message they hear in church and the public actions and statements of their religious leaders.
The hypocrisy is further underscored when compared to the suffering inflicted by the conflict. While the Church leaders stand with the President who ordered the invasion, countless civilians, including Orthodox Christians in Ukraine, have been killed, displaced, and had their lives destroyed. The silence or complicity of religious authorities in the face of such human catastrophe constitutes a grave moral failing in the eyes of many.
Ultimately, the image of priests standing solemnly beside Vladimir Putin at state occasions is more than just a political photo-op. It is a powerful visual representation of a relationship between Church and state that, according to many, has compromised the Church’s moral authority and betrayed the core values it claims to uphold. It highlights a profound hypocrisy where the robes of faith appear to bless the actions of a ruler whose policies stand in direct opposition to the very principles Christianity preaches.
Worldwide Temple of Aurora 