The Tyranny of ‘Shoulds’: Releasing the Burden of Unrealistic Life Expectations

We all carry an invisible blueprint for life, a meticulously crafted script dictating how the world should unfold. From childhood fairy tales to social media’s filtered realities, we absorb a potent cocktail of expectations that often bear little resemblance to the messy, unpredictable, and wonderfully imperfect world we actually inhabit. This unseen burden – the tyranny of ‘shoulds’ – can lead to profound disappointment, chronic frustration, and a pervasive sense of failure.

Let’s dismantle some of these pervasive, yet ultimately unrealistic, expectations.

The Myth of Universal Kindness and Reason

Perhaps one of the most ingrained yet damaging beliefs is that people should behave well, be nice, reasonable, and kind. We expect strangers to be courteous, colleagues to be considerate, and loved ones to always act with our best interests at heart. When confronted with rudeness, selfishness, or irrationality – which is a daily occurrence for most of us – we are often genuinely shocked and offended.

This expectation ignores the vast spectrum of human experience, motivation, and internal struggle. People are driven by fear, insecurity, misunderstanding, self-interest, and a myriad of factors invisible to us. To expect everyone to operate from a place of enlightened empathy is to set ourselves up for constant disillusionment. Reality is far more chaotic, and while kindness and reason exist, they are not universal defaults.

The Illusion of Effortless Wealth, Fame, and Success

Another heavy ‘should’ is the belief that life should lead to significant wealth, widespread fame, or effortless success. Social media, with its curated highlight reels and overnight sensations, has amplified this expectation to an unbearable degree. We see others’ perceived successes and assume our own paths should mirror them, or at least conclude in a similarly grand fashion.

The truth is, genuine success – however one defines it – is rarely effortless. It’s often built on years of unseen struggle, sacrifice, and an ample dose of luck. Wealth and fame, when they do arrive, often come with their own unique burdens, pressures, and an emptiness that the initial expectation never accounted for. Focussing on these external markers as the only valid outcomes diverts attention from genuine growth, personal fulfillment, and the quiet joys of a life well-lived, regardless of its public acclaim or financial heft.

The Demand for Divine Order and Perfect Justice

Then there are the existential ‘shoulds’: Life should make sense. God should intervene whenever anything goes wrong. Bad people should repent or be suitably punished and never get away with bad things.

This expectation stems from a deep human desire for order, meaning, and justice in a fundamentally random universe. When good people suffer, when natural disasters strike seemingly without cause, or when malicious individuals flourish without apparent consequence, our belief systems are shaken to their core. We look for a cosmic ledger, a divine hand, or an inevitable karmic payback that often simply doesn’t materialise in the ways we expect or on the timetables we prefer.

The universe, in its vast indifference, rarely conforms to our moral frameworks. Bad things happen to good people. Injustices persist. And while seeking justice is a noble pursuit, expecting it to be universally enforced by some higher power, or to unfold neatly within our lifetime, can lead to profound spiritual disillusionment and a sense of cosmic betrayal.

Why We Cling to These ‘Shoulds’

Why do we hold onto these unrealistic expectations so tightly? Perhaps it’s a security blanket against the terrifying arbitrariness of existence. Perhaps it’s an ingrained human desire for control, even if illusory. Cultural narratives, media saturation, and even well-meaning parental advice can subtly shape these beliefs from an early age. They offer a comforting, predictable framework, even if that framework is ultimately built on sand.

Releasing the Burden: Embracing Robust Realism

The antidote to the tyranny of ‘shoulds’ is not cynicism, but what one might call robust realism. It’s not about lowering our standards or abandoning our ideals, but recalibrating our lenses to perceive the world as it is, rather than as we think it should be.

Accept Human Imperfection: Understand that people are complex, flawed, and often operate from their own limited perspectives. This doesn’t excuse cruelty, but it allows for greater empathy and less shock. We can still strive for kindness, but we don’t expect it universally.
Redefine Success: Shift focus from external metrics to internal growth, meaningful relationships, personal contributions, and finding joy in the everyday. Success becomes a journey of becoming, not a destination of acquisition.
Embrace the Absurdity: Acknowledge that life often doesn’t make sense. There is suffering, there is randomness, and justice is often a human construct rather than a divine guarantee. This acceptance can lead to a kind of freedom – the freedom to create meaning in a meaningless world, to act justly because it’s right, not because it guarantees a reward.
Cultivate Resilience: When we expect life to be perfect, every deviation feels like a catastrophe. When we anticipate challenges and imperfections, we build the mental fortitude to navigate them with greater grace and adaptability.

Releasing the burden of unrealistic expectations isn’t about giving up on hope or striving for a better world. It’s about grounding ourselves in the present reality, finding peace in its imperfections, and discovering the profound strength that comes from accepting what is, while still working towards what can be. It’s a journey from demanding how life should play out, to gracefully engaging with how it actually does. And in that shift, we often find a more profound, resilient, and genuine sense of contentment.

Kerin Webb has a deep commitment to personal and spiritual development. Here he shares his insights at the Worldwide Temple of Aurora.