The Witch Trials: Why Women Accused Women

When we picture the witch trials of colonial America and early modern Europe – the frantic girls in Salem Village, the agonised confessions extracted under torture in Scotland, the bonfires blazing in German towns – our focus often lands on the terrified accused, the hysterical accusers, or the zealous judges. Yet one of the most haunting, and least discussed, facets lies in the uncomfortable truth: a significant proportion of those who levelled the deadly accusation of witchcraft against their neighbours were women themselves. They did so knowing, with chilling certainty, that the penalty could be hanging, burning, drowning, or a slow death in a filthy jail cell. Why would a woman, acutely aware of the stakes, turn her finger towards another woman, potentially sealing her sister’s doom? A close look at history reveals that the phenomenon of women accusing other women had several potential reasons.

Consider the landscape these women inhabited:

The Scarcity Trap: Life was fiercely competitive for basic resources – land, food, marriage prospects, even mere respect. In Salem Village, land disputes and church fractures fuelled the accusations; many accusers came from factions seeking to seize the land of convicted widows like Rebecca Nurse. In European villages facing famine or plague, blame needed a target. A woman living slightly outside the norm – the eccentric herbalist, the sharp-tongued widow refusing to remarry, the poor neighbour whose cow kept dying – became a convenient vessel for communal anxiety. Accusing her wasn’t just about superstition; it was sometimes a naked grab for her meager possessions or an attempt to restore a fragile sense of order by removing a perceived source of chaos. For a woman with little to lose, joining the chorus could feel like the best way to protect her own hold on survival.

Female Moral Authority: Women were entrusted with the role of guardians of purity, morality, and the household soul. Yet they were denied the institutional power – the pulpit, the bench, the legal authority – to enforce that role effectively. When a neighbour’s child fell ill after a quarrel, or butter wouldn’t churn, or a husband grew distant, the weight of supernatural blame often fell on the woman deemed spiritually lax or spiteful. To accuse another woman of witchcraft was, perversely, a way for an accuser to assert her own moral vigilance and piety. By identifying the “witch,” she proved herself a faithful defender of the godly order – a rare avenue for gaining social approval and spiritual credibility in a world where her voice was otherwise silenced in public spheres. It was a toxic bargain: gain validation by participating in the destruction of another woman’s life.

The Redirecting of Powerlessness: Women lived under constant threat of economic ruin and physical vulnerability. This pervasive sense of helplessness bred frustration and fear. In the absence of legitimate channels to challenge the sources of their insecurity the psyche seeks a proxy target. Accusing another woman allowed the displacement of this terrifying, undefined dread onto a concrete, punishable figure. It transformed amorphous anxiety into actionable righteous fury. The young girls of Salem – Abigail Williams, Betty Parris, Ann Putnam Jr. – weren’t just acting out greed; their accusations were likely amplified by genuine trauma, repressed sexuality within a suffocating Puritan regime, and the intoxicating, terrifying rush of finally being heard and feared by the powerful men who usually ignored them. Their power was borrowed, dangerous, and ultimately self-consuming.

The Illusion of Solidarity: Crucially, women weren’t a monolithic bloc. Loyalty was first to kin, then to immediate neighbourhood faction, then perhaps to shared religion or class – never to an abstract “sisterhood.” A wealthy farmer’s wife had vastly different interests and fears than an indentured servant or a destitute widow. Accusations often flowed downward along socio-economic lines or laterally between competing factions. The well-connected wife of a minister might accuse a troublesome poor neighbour; the anxious mother struggling to feed her children might eye the slightly better-off widow with suspicion and envy. The system actively prevented genuine solidarity by making women competitors for security and approval offered by the male-dominated structure. To see another woman as a rival threat, rather than a fellow sufferer, was often the rational, if horrifying, outcome of their circumstances.

Knowing the penalty didn’t deter the accuser because, in that moment of accusation, the perceived alternative – remaining passive, vulnerable, and potentially the next target – felt infinitely worse. To accuse was to seize a fleeting, dangerous semblance of agency: to define reality, to command the attention of authorities, to potentially remove a perceived threat, to prove one’s loyalty to the prevailing order. It was a Faustian bargain forged in the fires of desperation, where the cost was paid not in coin, but in the lives of other women, and ultimately, corroded the accuser’s own soul.

Understanding this isn’t about excusing the terrible harm caused. It’s about confronting the uncomfortable mechanism of how systemic oppression can turn the oppressed against each other. The women who accused weren’t merely “witch hunters”; they were often the product of a world that offered them few alternative paths to power, security, or dignity – hence why some (but not all) chose the cruel shortcut of pointing the finger at someone else who seemed even less secure.

This history holds a stark, enduring warning. When we see women undermining each other today – in vicious online mobs, workplace sabotage fuelled by insecurity, or the relentless policing of other women’s choices – we must look beyond surface-level nastiness. We must ask what perceived benefit is being offered to them by aligning with an oppressor? The flames of the past weren’t lit solely by hatred; they were kindled in an atmosphere of fear and of the desire for social advantage. We must therefore recognise that true solidarity isn’t born from ignoring our capacity for harm; it’s forged by honestly confronting the conditions that make harm seem like the best option, and then dismantling those conditions together.

Kerin Webb has a deep commitment to personal and spiritual development. Here he shares his insights at the Worldwide Temple of Aurora.